Upper Tribunal for Scotland adds UNCRC checks from 1 April
Scotland will build children’s rights into day‑to‑day tribunal practice from 1 April 2026. Fresh rules for the Upper Tribunal for Scotland, signed on 27 January and laid before Holyrood on 29 January, set out how ‘compatibility questions’ defined in section 31 of the UNCRC Incorporation (Scotland) Act 2024 will be handled, according to legislation.gov.uk. (legislation.gov.uk)
The Scottish Statutory Instrument (SSI 2026/33) updates four sets of Upper Tribunal procedure rules: the general rules from 2016, the social security rules from 2018, the local taxation rules from 2022 and the bus registration appeals rules from 2024. The changes give a single, common path for raising and managing UNCRC issues in civil cases. (legislation.gov.uk)
Put simply, any party can raise a compatibility question at any stage in proceedings. They are expected to set out the facts, circumstances and the legal basis for saying a UNCRC issue arises; and the tribunal can order more detail and list a separate hearing if needed. Proceedings can be paused (‘sisted’) while the issue is decided.
Once a compatibility question is accepted, the tribunal must tell three ‘relevant authorities’ - the Lord Advocate, the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland (CYPCS) and the Scottish Human Rights Commission (SHRC). Under the 2024 Act, those bodies can join the case so far as it relates to the compatibility point. The new rules set 14 days to signal an intention to take part and a further seven days to lodge written submissions, with the tribunal providing the papers. (legislation.gov.uk)
The tribunal may also hold the compatibility point as a stand‑alone hearing. Where the issue is significant or novel, the Upper Tribunal can refer it up to the Inner House of the Court of Session; a determination there can in turn reach the UK Supreme Court with permission. (legislation.gov.uk)
For readers across the North, this will crop up in familiar places. Cross‑border bus operators registering local services in Scotland, families appealing social security determinations, or firms contesting Scottish local taxation can all find themselves in the Upper Tribunal for Scotland. A children’s rights argument raised late in the day could now pause a case while the question is settled.
Practitioners will want to front‑load the work. If you intend to argue compatibility, set it out early and in writing, tie the facts to the rights engaged, and be ready to deal with a tight timetable. For public authorities, fast intimation and short deadlines will be the norm, so prepare a standing response and a briefing route to decision‑makers.
Ministers have put the changes on a formal footing as SSI 2026/33. The regulations were signed by Siobhian Brown on 27 January 2026, laid before the Scottish Parliament on 29 January, and come into force on 1 April 2026. The instrument sits alongside the existing Upper Tribunal rule‑sets already published on legislation.gov.uk.
The legal footing is clear. The 2024 Act defines a ‘compatibility question’, requires intimation to the Lord Advocate, CYPCS and SHRC, and allows references up to the Inner House - with a route on to the Supreme Court in some cases. Part 5 took effect on 16 July 2024 and underpins these tribunal changes. (legislation.gov.uk)
For northern families, operators and advisers who cross the Border for Scottish proceedings, the message is simple: children’s rights arguments now have a clear procedural home at tribunal level - and they may alter the pace and shape of a case.